Can You Really Earn 6.5% on a CD?
Six months ago, short-term Treasury bills looked unbeatable—but then headline CD offers began cresting above 6 percent. Savers everywhere wondered whether the advertised 6.5 percent yields were hype or a genuine opportunity to lock in inflation-beating returns.
“Maria,” a 38-year-old project manager, had $20,000 parked in a checking account earning 0.05 percent. Her goals:
The first thing Maria discovered was howrare6 percent CDs really are. Business Insider notes that finding CDs “offering a 6% Annual Percentage Yield (APY) or higher” is unusual, with only a handful of credit unions qualifying, and even those have geographic hurdles; for instance, Financial Partners Credit Union’s offer “typicallylimits membership to residents of specific areas in Southern California**.”
CNBC Select echoes that scarcity, stressing that Financial Partners Credit Union “offers an eight-month CD at a high rate of 6.50% APY ** but caps earnings on balances above $5,000.”
Table 1 – Snapshot of Top High-Yield Offers (April 2025)
| Institution | Term | APY | Membership / Deposit Caveats |
|---|---|---|---|
| Financial Partners Credit Union | 8 mo | 6.50 % | SoCal residents/workers; $5k cap |
| Credit Union of Southern California | 9 mo | 7.00 % | SoCal field of membership; $3k max (BI) |
| California Coast Credit Union | 12 mo | 9.50 % | San Diego/Imperial Counties; $2.5k max (BI) |
| CIBC Bank USA | 12 mo | 5.51 % | Nationwide; $1,000 min (CNBC) |
| Marcus by Goldman Sachs | 9 mo | 5.30 % | Nationwide; $500 min (CNBC) |
(BI = Business Insider extract, CNBC = CNBC Select extract)
Geographic & Membership Constraints
Maria lives in Denver, so the California-centric credit unions were out.
Early-Withdrawal & Renewal Pitfalls
A 6.5 percent headline rate is meaningless if you forfeit half of it in penalties. Wells Fargo’s fee schedule reminds savers that pulling money early from a CD under one year costs “3 months’ interest” for standard terms between 90–365 days, and that penalty could even “reduce…principal” if done too soon—language Wells Fargo customer disclosures spell out in detail **.
CNBC’s write-up adds a second caution: because penalties are usually a percentage of the principal, a mid-term withdrawal can erase most of the promised upside as “ penalty calculations are based on the CD term and principal **.”
Designing Maria’s Strategy
After research, Maria constructed a barbell CD ladder:
• $5,000 into Financial Partners CU (she qualified via an industry association and was comfortable with the balance cap).
• $10,000 into CIBC Bank USA’s 12-month CD at 5.51 percent.
• $5,000 kept in a high-yield savings account at 4.25 percent.
Why not plow the full $20k into the 6.5 percent CD? Two reasons:
- Liquidity—home-renovation cash will be needed in 9 months.
- Rate-cut hedge—if the Fed slashes rates later this year, having a 12-month slice earns above-market returns into 2026.
Projected Results (Using NerdWallet’s Calculator Logic)
NerdWallet’s calculator shows that a $5,000 CD earning 6.5 percent for eight months will net about $217 before taxes; meanwhile, the $10,000 at 5.51 percent for twelve months should earn $551. NerdWallet illustrates how compounding works by comparing “a $10,000 investment in a 1-year CD at 4% APY earning $400 **—so Maria’s blended strategy comfortably exceeds that baseline.
Risk Check: Inflation & Rate Direction
Historical data from Bankrate indicates that “CD rates peaked in late 2023 due to Federal Reserve rate hikes” and have been softening, yet “APYs on competitive CDs remain above the inflation rate **. Maria therefore treats 6.5 percent as opportunistic and time-sensitive.
Outcome After Eight Months
When Maria’s 6.5 percent CD matures, she plans to:
- Apply $5,150 (principal + interest) to the renovation.
- Evaluate prevailing rates. If one-year CDs are still above 5 percent, she’ll roll the funds; if not, she’ll divert to Treasury bills.
Practical Takeaways
• Yes, 6.5 percent CDs exist—but almost exclusively at small, membership-restricted credit unions.
• Early-withdrawal math matters—three months’ interest could wipe out your advantage.
• Laddering can blend liquidity with yield, especially when short-term CDs pay more than long-term.
• Keep an eye on the Fed; CNBC cautions that “ the Federal Reserve might lower rates in the future **, so today’s offers may not last.
Conclusion
Maria proved that an everyday saver, with diligent research and a bit of flexibility, can capture a 6.5 percent CD without sacrificing liquidity or safety. Her story underscores a broader lesson: high-yield opportunities favor the nimble. Act quickly, mind the fine print, and you, too, can turn a checking-account afterthought into an inflation-beating asset.
The information available on this website is a compilation of research, available data, expert advice, and statistics. However, the information in the articles may vary depending on what specific individuals or financial institutions will have to offer. The information on the website may not remain relevant due to changing financial scenarios; and so, we would like to inform readers that we are not accountable for varying opinions or inaccuracies. The ideas and suggestions covered on the website are solely those of the website teams, and it is recommended that advice from a financial professional be considered before making any decisions.